The Case of the Misguided Supervisors

Recently, when a union sought to organize the nurses at a California hospital, the nursing supervisors, called charge nurses, didn’t understand their proper role in the process. While the union was distributing cards for the nurses to indicate their desire for a representation election, several of the charge nurses participated in the union’s meetings and decided they wanted to join. Some of these charge nurses also encouraged nurses who reported to them to support the union as well.

One month before the election, the hospital discovered that charge nurses had supported the union even though their positions in the organization qualified them as supervisors. The charge nurses stopped advocating for the union, and some even encouraged non supervisory nurses to vote against representation. The election went ahead, and the union won representation.

The hospital challenged the election because of the pro-union activity by the nurses. However, the NLRB and the court both upheld the union.

Writing Assignment

Read The Case of the Misguided Supervisors in Chapter 14 of your text book. Use the Argosy University online library for additional research, and do the following in a Word document:

  • In 1–2 paragraphs, summarize the case and your research that relates to the case.
    • Why would an organization care whether its supervisors speak in favor of or against union representation? Explain and justify your answer.
    • How could the hospital in this example have prepared its supervisors to understand their proper role during an organizing campaign? Explain and justify your answer.In 2–3 pages, answer the following:

With your answers demonstrate that your understanding of the concepts is thorough and complete. Support your assertions with evidence, citing the appropriate sources.

Apply the SPA current guidelines to your work and use at least three resources in your response.

Use the following file naming convention:

Last name First Initial_M4_A2. For example, if your name is John Smith, your document will be named Smith J_M4_A2.doc

By Wednesday, July 6, 2016, deliver your assignment to the M4: Assignment 2 Dropbox.

Assignment 2 Grading Criteria Maximum Points
Clearly and concisely summarized the case in 1–2 paragraphs. 15
Identified, explained, and justified why an organization would care whether its supervisors speak in favor of or against union representation. 35
Identified, explained, and justified how the hospital in this example could have prepared its supervisors to understand their proper role during an organizing campaign. 35
Applied current SPA guidelines and supported assertions with evidence by using appropriate sources. Demonstrated a thorough and complete understanding of the concepts. 15
Total: 100


"Get 15% discount on your first 3 orders with us"
Use the following coupon

Order Now

For order inquiries        1-800-700-6200

Hi there! Click one of our representatives below and we will get back to you as soon as possible.

Chat with us on WhatsApp